[00:00:03]
[CALL TO ORDER]
GOOD EVENING EVERYBODY.I'D LIKE TO CALL THE, UH, MEETING TO ORDER.
WELCOME TO THE CITY OF DUBLIN ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW BOARD MEETING BEING HELD AT 5 5 5 5 PERIMETER DRIVE.
THE MEETING CAN ALSO BE ACCESSED VIA LIVESTREAM VIDEO RECORDED ON THE CITY'S WEBSITE.
WE WELCOME PUBLIC PARTICIPATION, INCLUDING PUBLIC COMMENT ON THE CASES THE MEETING PROCEDURE, UH, UH, FOR EACH CASE.
THIS EVENING WILL BEGIN WITH A STAFF PRESENTATION FOLLOWED BY AN OPPORTUNITY FOR THE APPLICANT TO MAKE A PRESENTATION IF DESIRED.
THE APPLICANT MAY PRESENT FIRST.
THE BOARD WILL THEN ASK CLARIFYING QUESTIONS OF BOTH THE APPLICANT AND STAFF, FOLLOWED BY PUBLIC COMMENTS BEFORE DELIBERATING ON EACH CASE.
SO IF ANYBODY WISHING TO MAKE A PUBLIC COMMENT WILL BE INVITED TO COME FORWARD TO THE PODIUM FOR EACH APPLICATION, PLEASE ENSURE THE GREEN LIGHT IS ON.
STATE YOUR NAME AND YOUR ADDRESS FOR THE RECORDS.
WE, WE REQUEST THAT YOU KEEP YOUR COMMENTS TO THREE MINUTES OR LESS.
AND AS WE DO ON EACH MEETING, WE'LL STAND IN FOR THE PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE.
I PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, AND TWO, THE REPUBLIC REPUBLIC FOR WHICH IT STANDS, ONE NATION UNDER GOD, INDIVISIBLE, WITH LIBERTY AND JUSTICE.
JAMIE, COULD YOU CALL THE RULE? YES, MS. COOPER IS ABSENT THIS EVENING.
[ACCEPTANCE OF DOCUMENTS AND APPROVAL OF MEETING MINUTES]
MAKE A MOTION TO ACCEPT, UH, THE, TO ACCEPT THE DOCUMENTS INTO THE RECORD AND APPROVE THE A RB MEETING MINUTES FROM APRIL 9TH, 2025 AND APRIL 23RD, 2025.IS THERE A SECOND? I'LL MAKE A SECOND.
THE ARCHITECTURE REVIEW BOARD IS RESPONSIBLE FOR THE REVIEW OF CONSTRUCTION AND MODIFICATIONS OR ALTERATIONS TO ANY SITE IN THE AREA SUBJECT TO THE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW UN SUBJECT TO ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW.
UNDER PROVISION OF THE ZONING CODE SECTION 1 5 3 0.170, THE BOARD HAS THE DECISION, DECISION MAKING RESPONSIBILITY ON THESE CASES.
ANYBODY WHO INTENDS TO ADDRESS THE BOARD ON THE CA ON CASES THIS EVENING MUST BE SWORN IN.
SO ANYBODY INTENDING TO ADDRESS THE BOARD THIS EVENING, PLEASE RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND AND ANSWER IN THE AFFIRMATIVE.
DO YOU SWEAR OR AFFIRM TO TELL THE TRUTH, THE WHOLE TRUTH, AND NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH IN YOUR TESTIMONY TO THIS BOARD? THANK YOU.
[Case #25-033INF]
SO CASE NUMBER 25 DASH 0 3 3 INFORMAL REVIEW.FISHER RES, UH, OFFICIAL RESIDENCE REQUEST A REVIEW AND A NON-BINDING FEEDBACK FOR THE CONSTRUCTION OF A NEW SINGLE FAMILY HOME ON PID 2 73 DASH 0 0 0 0 31.
THE 2.23 ACRE SITE IS ZONED, UH, HDHR, HISTORIC RESIDENTIAL DISTRICT AND IS LOCATED APPROXIMATELY 130 FEET NORTH OF SHORT STREET ON THE EAST SIDE OF SOUTH RIVER, SOUTH RIVERVIEW STREET.
THANK YOU, MR. CHAIRMAN AND GOOD EVENING BOARD MEMBERS.
THE SITE IS OUTLINED IN YELLOW HERE.
IT IS ZONED HISTORIC RESIDENTIAL AS THE CHAIR MENTIONED.
IT'S A NEWLY SPLIT LOT AND AS YOU MIGHT EXPECT, THERE ARE SOME FLOODPLAIN IMPACTS.
THESE ARE THE GENERAL SURROUNDINGS.
THE AREA IS MOSTLY COMPOSED OF BACKGROUND BUILDINGS AND VACANT LOTS.
THE QUARTER ACRE SITES, IT'S ABOVE THE SCIOTO RIVER AND THE 1% ANNUAL CHANCE FLOOD LINE IS INDICATED BY THE BLUE DASH.
THE PROPOSED MAIN ELEVATION IS A ONE AND A HALF STORY FACADE.
IT'S GOT SIMPLE TRADITIONAL FORMS WHICH FOLLOW GUIDELINES 5.0 AND 5.1 B.
THERE IS A PROJECTING L THAT ALLOWS A FRONT DOOR UNDERNEATH A PORCH.
THIS IS A VERY TRADITIONAL ARRANGEMENT.
THERE'S A SMALL SHED ROOF ABOVE THE PORCH, WHICH WILL NEED A WAIVER REQUEST.
WHEN WE GET TO MINOR PROJECT, THE GARAGES ARE DIMINISHED IN IMPORTANCE, WHICH IS A REALLY GOOD THING.
THE BOARDS REQUESTED TO COMMENT ON THE MASSING AND THE ROOF PITCH WAIVER PLEASE.
UM, THE INDICATED MATERIALS INCLUDE STONE FOUNDATION AND ENTRY AREA HORIZONTAL SIDING ON THE L VERTICAL SIDING.
ON THE SECOND STORY, THERE MAY
[00:05:01]
BE A LITTLE BIT OF AN INTERFACE, UM, UH, WITH THAT VERTICAL SIDING AND THEN THE HORIZONTAL SIDING ON THE LEFT SIDE THAT WE MAY WANNA TALK ABOUT.WE HAVE TWO DIFFERENT ROOF TYPES AND THE BOARD IS REQUESTED TO COMMENT ON THESE EARLY MATERIAL SELECTIONS.
THE REAR FACADE NEEDS A HEIGHT WAIVER AND, UH, WE'LL BE REQUESTING COMMENT ON THAT.
THIS FACADES BROKEN INTO THREE GABLES.
THE CENTER PORTION COMES FORWARD.
AS YOU CAN SEE, DECKS ARE SHOWN, UH, THAT UPPER CENTER PORTION OF THE DECK IS PROPOSED TO BE SCREENED IN.
SO WE'VE GOT SOME CONCERNS WITH SOME MATERIALS AND MASSING EFFECTS AND WHETHER THAT WILL READ AS A SOLID BLOCK DEPENDING ON THE MATERIAL THAT'S SHOWN.
UM, OVERALL, THE, UH, WINDOW ARRANGEMENTS APPEAR APPROPRIATE AT THIS POINT, AND THE MATERIALS ARE ESSENTIALLY AS PROPOSED ON THE FRONT.
THE NORTH SIDE SHOWS HOW THE, UH, RIVERSIDE, IF YOU WILL, IS ARRANGED WHERE THE MASSING GENERALLY SLOPES DOWN TOWARDS THE RIVER.
UH, THE ROOF FORMS ARE SIMPLE.
THE PERPENDICULAR GABLES ARE OF SIMILAR HEIGHT AND NOT OVERWHELMING EACH OTHER.
THIS LENS OF COHESIVENESS AND, AND PERPETUATES HISTORIC PROPORTIONS, THE WINDOWS ARE APPROPRIATELY ARRANGED.
THE REAR DAL LINE AND THE MATERIALS ARE AGAIN, THE STONE AND THE HORIZONTAL SIDING.
THE SOUTH SIDE IS ESSENTIALLY THE SAME TYPE OF ARRANGEMENT.
YOU CAN SEE THE GARAGE, UM, LAYOUT, ESPECIALLY IN THE 3D MODEL.
AND AGAIN, THE MASSING GENERALLY STEPS DOWN THE HILL TO THE RIVER.
UM, WE SEE THE HORIZONTAL AND VERTICAL SIDING AND THE STONE.
AND OVERALL, WE APPRECIATE THE APPLICANT'S EFFORTS AT THIS EARLY STAGE.
SO QUESTIONS FOR CONSIDERATION INCLUDE THE MASSING, ESPECIALLY THE FRONT AND THE REAR.
UH, THE SUPPORT FOR THE ELEVATIONS AS CONCEPTUALLY SHOWN WAIVERS FOR THE REAR HEIGHT AND THE ROOF PITCH, WHETHER OR NOT THE MATERIALS APPEAR ACCEPTABLE AT THIS, AGAIN, THIS EARLY STAGE AND ESPECIALLY THE PORCH SCREENING.
AND THEN ANY OTHER CONSIDERATIONS BY THE BOARD.
AND WITH THAT, I'M HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS.
ANYBODY HAVE ANYTHING FOR SARAH? NO.
YOU HAD, THERE WAS ONE COMMENT ABOUT THE DR, I THINK IT WAS, WAS THE DRIVEWAY.
THERE WAS SOMETHING ABOUT THE 20 FOOT.
THERE WAS A COMMENT IN THERE ABOUT DRIVE.
CAN YOU JUST MAYBE REF, I LOOKED AT IT, I WASN'T QUITE SURE 'CAUSE THE DRIVEWAY DIDN'T LOOK WIDER THAN 22, BUT I'M NOT SURE WHAT, WHAT'S YOUR COMMENT? WE JUST, YES.
WE NEED TO CONFIRM THAT NOT ONLY THE WIDTH, UM, IS BELOW THE, OR AT THE MAXIMUM ALLOWED BY CODE AND ALSO TO MAKE SURE THAT THE DRIVEWAY SETBACK IS BEING MET.
COMMENT IN THE STAFF REPORT JUST TO MAKE SURE WE TRACK IT JUST AN FYI FOR NEXT STEPS.
AND, AND I GUESS I UNDERSTAND TOO, THE IMPACT OF THE TURNAROUND TO BE ABLE TO GET OUT OF THAT TWO DOOR GARAGE HAS, HAS TO BE WHATEVER THE MINIMUM NEEDS TO BE TO MAPLE TO MAKE THAT TURN RIGHT.
SO THAT'S GONNA BE A LITTLE BIT OF A DELICATE JIGSAW PUZZLE THERE.
UH, THE APPLICANT I'D LIKE TO COME UP AND, UH, COMMENT OR CLARIFY.
UH, MY NAME IS JEFF, MEMBER, MEMBER HOMES.
WE'RE THE, UH, BUILDER FOR THE HOME HERE FOR THE OFFICIAL RESIDENCE.
UM, UH, WE'RE EXCITED ABOUT, UH, THIS PROJECT IN, IN THE WAY IT IS SHAPING UP TO THIS POINT.
UH, SARAH HAS DONE A, A NICE JOB OF EXPLAINING KINDA HOW WE'VE, UH, ARRIVED WHERE WE ARE AT THIS MOMENT, AND, UM, JUST HAPPY TO, TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS YOU MAY HAVE.
DOES ANYBODY HAVE ANY CLARIFYING, MAYBE JUST A COUPLE OF THINGS JUST ON FOR ME.
JUST, UM, UH, THERE WAS ONE COMMENT IN THE STAFF REPORT ABOUT THE, THE STONE.
UH, LET'S SEE, THE, WHERE THE STONE ON THE SOUTH SIDE, WHERE IT SITS ON THE, ON THE FOUNDATION.
AND FOR ME, THE FRONT IS AT KIND OF ONE LEVEL AND IT STEPS DOWN IN THE, CERTAINLY AROUND THE, THE, THE GARAGE.
IT DOESN'T MATCH THE FLOOR LEVEL AND IT DOESN'T MATCH THE BE AT THE FRONT.
SO JUST MAYBE A LITTLE BIT, I MEAN, HOW, HOW DID YOU THINK ABOUT WHY THAT, WHY THE STONE LOOK SITS IN THAT SPOT OR WHY IT LOOKS LIKE THAT? SURE.
THE, UM, I THINK RIGHT NOW WE JUST COVERED THE FOUNDATION, THE POURED WALL PORTION
[00:10:01]
OF IT.AND THEN ON THE FRONT IT DOES COME UP A LITTLE BIT HIGHER THAN THAT RIGHT NOW.
UH, THERE'S NOTHING THAT PREVENTS US FROM BRINGING THAT FRONT LINE ALL THE WAY AROUND.
UH, WE WERE TRYING TO BE A LITTLE BIT CAUTIOUS OF CROWDING THE WINDOW TRIM, BUT I THINK THERE'S PROBABLY PLENTY OF WAYS TO OKAY.
I, I MEAN, I, I WOULD SAY FROM MY SIDE, IT JUST, IF YOU PICK SOMETHING IN MY MIND, I WAS LOOKING AT LOGIC, EITHER IT WOULD BE KIND OF AT THE FLOOR, THE, THE, THE LIVING FLOOR LEVEL WOULD BE KIND OF, EVEN WITH THE FRONT, I'M NOT SURE I HAVE A SURE.
BUT JUST IT WOULD LOOK LOGICAL ON THE SITE.
AND LOOKING AT THE 3D MODELING, IF THAT'S WHAT YOU'RE CALLING OUT THERE WITH THE SINGLE DOOR, WITH THE ONE SINGLE GARAGE AND THEN THE TWO GARAGES THAT WHERE YOU'RE CALLING OUT THAT CORNER.
SO IF YOU SEE WHERE THE, WHERE THE, UH, I DON'T KNOW, THE FOUNDATION, UM, IS LOWER, BUT IF YOU LOOK AT THE SOUTH SIDE, IT'S NOT REALLY AT THE FLOOR LEVEL EITHER.
SO IT JUST, IT'S NOT AT THE FLOOR LEVEL, THE GARAGE OR THE FLOOR LEVEL OF THE, OF WHATEVER'S AROUND THERE.
SO IT JUST FEELS LIKE IT'S KIND OF IN THE MIDDLE SOMEWHERE.
FOR ME, IT'D MAKE MORE SENSE IF IT WAS EVEN OR AT A DIFFERENT LEVEL.
UM, AND THEN THE OTHER ONE JUST, UM, FROM THE, SO THE, I HAVE TO ADMIT, WHEN I LOOKED AT, SO THE, THE, THE, UH, FRONT TOP, THE, THE, UH, VERTICAL SIDING, YOU THINK, YOU THINK THAT'S LIKE FOUR INCH SIDING? IT WAS HARD TO JUST TELL IT.
SO OUR TYPICAL, UH, BOARD AND BATTEN TYPICALLY HAS LIKE A, A ONE BY TWO FOR THE BATTEN STRIP.
UM, AND THEN WE CAN SPREAD THAT DEPENDING ON WHAT WE THINK, UM, YOU KNOW, IS APPROPRIATE.
UH, IF WE SPREAD THAT OUT EIGHT OR NINE INCHES.
IT, IT'S, WE CAN MAKE THAT WHATEVER YOU GUYS DEEM NECESSARY, BUT YOU'LL HAVE THAT ALL THE WAY AROUND.
ALL THAT VERTICAL WILL ALL BE BOARD AND BATTEN AT THE SAME.
'CAUSE ON ONE SIDE IT LOOKED, IT LOOKED MORE SIDING THAN BOARD AND BATTEN, BUT IT'S ALL BOARD AND BATTEN ALL THE WAY AROUND.
UM, DO YOU HAVE ANOTHER QUE I'D LIKE TO ASK A QUESTION? YES, GO AHEAD.
SO, UM, YOU KNOW, I LOVE, I ALWAYS WANNA THINK ABOUT WHAT THOSE HOUSES ON THE BACK ARE GONNA LOOK LIKE TO PEOPLE ON THE RIVER.
UM, I NOTICED THAT STAFF, UH, HAD MENTIONED THE SCREEN ENCLOSURE MM-HMM
AND, UM, THAT YOU WERE MADE AWARE OF THAT CONCERN.
IS THERE ANY RESPONSE TO THAT? SURE.
SO A COUPLE THINGS WE'LL DO ON THE REAR PORCH THERE IS, IS THE, THE UPPER DECK PORTION WILL HAVE A, A DRY SCAPE TYPE OF A SYSTEM THAT WATERPROOFS THAT.
AND THEN WE'LL HAVE A BEADBOARD CEILING UNDERNEATH OF EVERYTHING THAT IS THE FIRST FLOOR DECK HEIGHT.
SO THAT'LL LOOK LIKE A FINISHED PORCH CEILING UNDERNEATH OF THERE.
UH, SO CERTAINLY FROM BELOW, IF YOU'RE DOWN THERE LOOKING UP, YOU'LL SEE ALL FINISHED.
THERE WON'T BE ANY EXPOSED FRAMING OR ANYTHING LIKE THAT.
UM, NOW THE PORTION WITH THE SCREEN, THERE ARE APP, UH, PRODUCTS AVAILABLE TO US THAT ARE A LITTLE BIT MORE OF A LOW VISIBILITY TYPE OF A SCREENING THAT WE SHOULD BE ABLE TO USE IN THIS CASE TO KEEP THAT FEELING MORE OPEN, UM, AND LESS DARKER AND ENCLOSED, WHICH IS WHAT OUR CLIENT'S GONNA WANT ANYWAYS.
THEY OBVIOUSLY HERE FOR THE VIEW, YOU KNOW, TO THE RIVER.
SO, UH, HAPPY TO NAME THAT PRODUCT.
WE NEED TO IDENTIFY EXACTLY THE, THE, THE SPECIFIC PRODUCT WE NEED TO USE THERE.
BUT I DO KNOW THOSE ARE AVAILABLE TO US AND BE HAPPY TO USE THAT.
AND MAYBE, I DON'T KNOW IF WE, WE PROBABLY DON'T HAVE AN OPACITY REGULATING SOMETHING ON SCREENING ANYWHERE THAT WE USE SOMEPLACE ELSE.
'CAUSE WE DON'T JUST ONLY TO GIVE A, ONLY GIVE GUIDANCE ON SOMEHOW.
IT, WE DON'T HAVE ANY EXPERIENCE WITH THIS.
AND IN FACT, WE EVEN, UM, CONTACTED OHIO HERITAGE, UM, TO FIND OUT, YOU KNOW, THEY HAD ANY, UM, THE SHIPPO'S OFFICE, IF THEY HAD ANY EXPERIENCE WITH SCREENING IN, UM, 'CAUSE WE'VE HAD SOME REQUESTS, JUST INFORMAL REQUESTS AND, AND THEY AGREED WITH US THAT THE IDEA IS TO MAKE IT AS TRANSPARENT AS POSSIBLE.
SO THAT'S, THAT'S WHAT WE'RE LOOKING FOR.
UM, SO BASED ON THE SPECIFIC MATERIALS THAT WILL COME IN, WE CAN CONSIDER THAT.
IF YOU MAY, IF YOU HAVE AN EXAMPLE THAT WOULD BE GREAT FOR THE, WHEN YOU GET THE MINOR PROJECT REVIEW.
UM, MY LAST ONE IS ON THE ROOF PITCH, THE ONE ON THE FRONT, THE THREE 12, IS THERE ANY WAY TO MAKE IT FOUR JUST TO MAKE IT CONFORM OR IS IT JUST TO MAKE IT EASIER ON THE, JUST THERE'S NOT A CONDITION RIGHT.
THERE'S NOTHING PREVENTING IT PHYSICALLY FROM BEING FOUR 12.
I THINK IT'S JUST A, UM, WE'VE APPROVED A LOT OF THREE 12.
SO, I MEAN, I'M NOT SURE ANY OF US ARE OPPOSED, BUT, UH, IT'S JUST CLEANER IF IT JUST FITS INTO THE, INTO THE CODE.
IF IT, IF IT LOOKS LIKE IT WORKS FOR THE, FOR YOUR CLIENT.
WE CAN, WE, WE CAN DRAW IT AT FOUR 12 AND MAKE SURE THAT IT YEP.
UH, SO YOU WANNA, YEAH, YOU WANT, OKAY.
[00:15:01]
DISCUSSION.ANYBODY COMMENTING ON THE, I'D SAY MASS FRONT BACK? I THINK THE FRONT, I LIKE THE FRONT.
I THINK IT SEEMS APPROPRIATE FOR WHAT'S, WELL, NOT WHAT'S DOWN THERE.
'CAUSE THERE'S
AND I AGREE THE BACK MASSING HAS BEEN CONSISTENT PRETTY WELL JUST BECAUSE OF THE, UH, ELEVATION CHANGE.
IT'S VERY SIMILAR TO WHAT WE'VE BEEN APPROVING LATELY AND IT, TO ME IT LOOKS GOOD.
THE FRONT I THINK LOOKS GREAT.
I THINK THE WHOLE THING'S GOOD AND IN THE BACK I APPRECIATE IT BEING SYMMETRIC.
I THINK WE'VE ALWAYS, SOME OF IT, JUST THE WAY YOU'VE DISPLACED EVERYTH THAT FOR ME, I THINK ALL SIDES, UH, LOOK, LOOK, UH, LOOK WELL DONE.
ANYBODY HAVE A COMMENT ON? UH, I'LL SAY JUST THE, THE, I'LL SAY HOW THE BACK FITS IN.
ANYTHING ANYTHING STRIKES OUT STANDS OUT TO ANYBODY ON ELEVATION? NOPE.
I I I, TO GO ALONG WITH WHAT YOU JUST SAID, THE REAR, I LIKE THE SIMPLICITY OF IT AND THE SYMMETRICALITY, I THINK IT, IT LOOKS GOOD.
UH, HEIGHT AND FRONT SHED, ROOF PITCHES, EVERYBODY.
I MEAN, IS ANYBODY HAVE AN ISSUE WITH, I MEAN, FROM THE CITY? I THINK WE'RE, WE'VE SEEN THAT THERE, IT MIGHT BE HIGHER THAN MOST, BUT I THINK IT FITS IN, I THINK IT FITS IN WHERE THE, THE SLOPE COMES DOWN HARD THERE.
SO ANYBODY ISSUE, IF YOU CAN MAKE THE, IF YOU CAN MAKE THE SHED PROOF LOOK CONFORM, THEN THAT JUST MAKES IT, IT MAKES IT A LITTLE EASIER.
UM, MATERIALS, ANY, YEAH, OBVIOUSLY WE'LL WANNA SEE THE SCREENING ONCE YOU GET A SAMPLE OF THAT.
SO TRYING TO, AGAIN, TRYING TO MAKE IT AS TRANSPARENT AS YOU POSSIBLY CAN WITH THAT ASPECT OF IT, BUT ALSO SERVING THE PURPOSE THAT THEY WANT TO.
YEAH, I, I'M, I'VE ALREADY EXPRESSED THAT, SO I'M GOOD
I THINK THERE IS, STAFF SAID THERE'S A LOT OF RAILING BACK THERE, SO, UH, I THINK, UH, TO MAKE SURE THAT IT LOOKS APPROPRIATE WHEN YOU BRING BACK, UH, I DON'T SEE ANYTHING WITH THAT, BUT CERTAINLY TO MAKE SURE IT, IT LOOKS, UH, IT'S NOT ALL RAILING IN THE BACK AND IT, UH, IT LOOKS APPROPRIATE.
UH, ANYTHING ELSE? I MEAN, IS THERE ANYTHING ANYBODY SEES ON THIS ONE? NOT, NOPE.
I DON'T THINK THERE'S ANYTHING.
SARAH, YOU GOOD? NO, AND WE HAD NO PUBLIC COMMENTS.
YEAH, I THINK FROM OUR SIDE, I THINK IT LOOKS FROM A FIRST GO, I THINK IT'S DONE WELL.
I MEAN, DO YOU NEED ANY CLARIFY, ANYTHING CLARIFYING HERE? I THINK, UH, ANYTHING WE CAN MAKE SURE THAT YOU GOT FROM THE COMMENTS THAT I DON'T THINK SO.
SARAH, IS THERE ANYTHING THAT WE NEED? I FEEL LIKE NO, I THINK WE'RE, AS LONG AS YOU GUYS ARE HAPPY WE'RE YEAH, IT'S GOOD.
I THINK THEN THE, THE, THE COMMENTS IN THERE, I THINK A FEW THINGS.
I THINK THE RAILING DRIVEWAY AND HOW A FEW THINGS FIT IN THERE THAT ARE, I THINK ARE SPELLED OUT QUITE CLEARLY IN THE STAFF REPORT.
BUT OTHERWISE, I THINK IT'S, UH, IT'S FOR, FOR FIRST INFORMAL, IT'S QUITE, UH, IT'S QUITE WELL DONE.
[Case #25-025MPR]
ONE IS CASE, UH, NUMBER 25 0 25 MINOR PROJECT REVIEW.UH, REQUEST FOR REVIEW AND APPROVAL OF MINOR PROJECT OF A MINOR PROJECT REVIEW TO ALLOW FOR THE CONSTRUCTION OF A NEW HOME ON PID 2 3 7 0 1 3 5 5 8 ON A 0.727 ACRE LOT ZONED HDHS, HISTORIC RESIDENTIAL DISTRICT AND NOW AND IS LOCATED APPROXIMATELY 200 FEET NORTH OF SHORT STREET ON THE EAST SIDE OF, UH, SOUTH RIVERVIEW STREET.
THIS PROJECT IS RIGHT NEXT DOOR TO THE PREVIOUS PROJECT.
THIS IS A, UM, QUARTER ACRE LOT APPROXIMATELY ALSO ZONED HISTORIC RESIDENTIAL AND AFFECTED BY THE RIVER IN JANUARY OF THIS YEAR.
WE HAD AN INFORMAL AND WE TALKED ABOUT THE OVERALL MASSING, WHICH WAS SUPPORTED.
UM, LARGER WINDOWS WERE SUGGESTED AND, UH, SIMPLIFICATION OF MATERIALS WAS ALSO SUGGESTED.
THESE AGAIN, ARE THE GENERAL SURROUNDINGS AND AS WE SAW PREVIOUSLY, IT'S MOSTLY BACKGROUND BUILDINGS AND VACANT LOTS.
AND AGAIN, THIS SITS ABOVE THE SCIOTO RIVER.
UM, AND THE 1% ANNUAL CHANCE OF FLOOD IS NOTED WITH THE BLUE DASH.
THE PROPOSED FRONT FACADE IS MUCH LIKE AT INFORMAL.
SOME CHANGES INCLUDE THICKENING OF THE COLUMNS AT THE FRONT DOOR,
[00:20:01]
WINDOWS AND HARDWARE ADDED TO THE GARAGE DOOR TO AVOID MONOTONOUS MATERIALS PER THE GUIDELINES.WINDOW SIZES WERE HARD TO INCREASE DUE TO THE INTERIOR LAYOUT, SO STAFF REQUESTED SHUTTERS AND THESE HAVE BEEN PROVIDED AND NOW WE HAVE A CONDITION OF APPROVAL THAT THAT JUST RECOMMENDS.
WE NEED TO KNOW WHAT THOSE MATERIALS ARE PRIOR TO BUILDING PERMIT.
SARAH, JUST A QUICK INTERRUPTION IF YOU DON'T MIND.
WHEN YOU SAY SHUTTERS, THEY WERE SEA SHUTTERS ON THE LOWER LEVEL, ARE THEY ALSO GONNA BE ON THE UPPER LEVEL OR JUST ON THE LOWER LEVEL? THEY WERE NOT ADDED ON THE UPPER LEVEL.
JUST THOSE, THE LOWER THANK YOU STAFF DID QUESTION THE SHAKE PANELS ON THE FIRST FLOOR.
UM, YOU CAN CAN SEE THE, UM, MATERIAL EXAMPLE ON THE RIGHT HAND SIDE OVER THERE.
UH, THEY'RE VERY REGULAR IN APPEARANCE AND PERHAPS NOT AUTHENTIC, BUT WE ALSO FOUND THAT THEY WERE APPROVED FOR 53 NORTH RIVERVIEW.
SO THAT'S SOMETHING TO TAKE INTO CONSIDERATION.
UM, THEY WERE USED AT 53 IN ORDER TO REDUCE THE BUSYNESS OF THE FACADE, AND THAT WAS ONE OF THE BOARD'S COMMENTS HERE AS WELL.
SO IT MAY VERY WELL BE APPROPRIATE.
UH, THE WAIVERS HERE INCLUDE THE SHED ROOF PITCH ON THE REAR FACADE.
THERE ARE THREE WAIVERS ALSO INCLUDING TWO ROOF PITCHES AND TWO LOCATIONS IN THE BOXES.
THE DECKING MATERIAL IN TWO LOCATIONS WITH THE ARROWS, AND THEN THE REAR BUILDING HEIGHT, WHICH IS 40 FEET BASED ON THE SLOPE AND THE TOPOGRAPHY.
OTHERWISE, IT'S AS PRESENTED AT INFORMAL AND, UH, WE DO APPRECIATE THE APPROPRIATE WINDOW AND DOOR ARRANGEMENTS.
LOOKING AT THE SIDE ELEVATION STARTING WITH THE NORTH, WE DO HAVE A CONCERN ABOUT THAT CROSS GABLE SIZE RELATIVE TO THE PARALLEL GABLE SIZE.
IT WON'T BE HIGHLY VISIBLE, BUT IT DOES SEEM TO BE A LITTLE BIT OVERWHELMING.
UH, THE NORTH SIDE SHOWS THE WAIVER ROOF PITCHES THAT I POINTED OUT ON THE REAR.
UM, AND AGAIN, WE HAVE APPROPRIATE WINDOW PLACEMENT FOR THE SOUTH.
UM, AGAIN, GOOD WINDOW PLACEMENT.
UM, THESE WINDOWS FOR THE GARAGE WERE PAIRED BASED ON COMMENTS FROM THE BOARD.
AT THE INFORMAL, THE FRONT ENTRY IS SEEN, MOVE SLIGHTLY FORWARD OF THE MAIN PLANE OF THE HOUSE, AS IS THE CENTER REAR GETTING INTO MATERIALS AND COLORS.
THE ROOF SHALL BE THE CERTAINTY LANDMARK IN THE WEATHERED WOOD.
AND UH, AGAIN, ALL THOSE MATERIALS ARE UP FRONT.
UH, COATED METALS GROUP WILL BE THE STANDING SEAM IN IRON ORE, LOW GLOSS.
ALL SIDING AND TRIM MATERIALS ARE THE HARDY PLANK, WHICH DOES NOT REQUIRE A WAIVER.
THE SHAKE, AGAIN, IS UPFRONT BOARD AND BATTEN IS SMOOTH WITH THE 12 INCH ON CENTER BATTENS.
AND THEN THE TRIM AND THE DECORATIVE PANELS ARE ALSO SMOOTH.
HARDY BOARD THE STONE FOR THE FOUNDATION, CHIMNEY AND FIRST FLOOR.
UM, PLEASE LOOK AT THE SAMPLE UP FRONT, WHICH APPEARS TO BE A LITTLE BIT DIFFERENT THAN AS SHOWN ON THE SCREEN.
IT'S THAT QUIST DIMENSIONAL IN BEAVER CREEK.
UM, THE DECK AND THE PORCH COLUMNS ARE GONNA BE MADE OUT OF THE HARDY SMOOTH MATERIAL.
AND THE COLORS ARE ALABASTER FOR THE BOARD AND BATTEN AND TRIM, AND THAT'S REALLY MORE OF AN IVORY THAN A WHITE, THE OYSTER BAY FOR THE SHAKE, WHICH IS THAT GREENISH GRAY.
AND THEN THE COLUMNS AND THE PANELS ARE ALSO ALABASTER.
OTHER MATERIALS INCLUDE A WOOD DOOR FROM CLOPAY WITH WINDOWS AND HARDWARE.
UH, WE DID PUSH FOR SOME GREATER DETAIL TO HELP BREAK UP THAT MASSING OF THE GARAGE DOORS.
MARVIN ULTIMATE WINDOWS AND DOORS, THEY ARE ALL GOING TO BE CASEMENT WINDOWS SLIDERS OR FRENCH STYLE FOR THAT FRONT ENTRY.
AND THE REASON WHY WE'RE ALL RIGHT WITH EBONY HERE IS IT SOUNDS LIKE A SONG.
IT GOES WITH THE IVORY COLORED PAINT THAT'S PROPOSED FOR THE BODY.
AND THIS IS A NEW BUILD, SO IT'S
[00:25:01]
A LITTLE BIT LESS TRADITIONAL, IF YOU WILL.UM, AND THEN THE LIGHTING IS FROM VISUAL COMFORT AS SHOWN.
THE 40 FOOT REAR HEIGHT, THE THREE 12 ROOF PITCHES, THE TREX DECKING AND STAFF SUPPORTS ALL THREE REQUESTS AS NOTED IN THE REPORT FOR THE REVIEW CRITERIA.
THEY ARE ALL MET, MET WITH CONDITIONS OR WAIVERS OR NOT APPLICABLE.
SO OUR RECOMMENDATION IS, AGAIN, APPROVAL OF ALL THREE WAIVERS AND APPROVAL OF THE MINOR PROJECT WITH ONE CONDITION.
UH, WE DON'T NEED THE FIRST CONDITION.
WE HAVE THAT INFORMATION IN FRONT OF US.
AND WITH THAT, I'M HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS.
ANYBODY CLARIFYING? OKAY, THINK WE'RE GOOD.
IF YOU COULD JUST STATE YOUR NAME AND ADDRESS.
UH, 7 4 2 2 SILVERLEAF COURT, COLUMBUS, OHIO.
ANYTHING YOU WANNA ADD OR CLARIFY? IS THERE ANYTHING IN THERE THAT, UH, I BELIEVE SARAH DID A GREAT JOB.
UM, ANYTHING I SAY WILL BE REPEATING HER
IF YOU JUST STAND THERE FOR, I DON'T KNOW IF WE HAVE TOO MANY COMMENTS, BUT, UH, ANYBODY HAVE ANYTHING FOR THE APPLICANT? I DO.
JUST IF YOU COULD TALK ABOUT THE ROOF SHINGLES AND THE STRAIGHT LINE INSTEAD OF THE NO, YES, YES, YES.
SO NOW I'M GETTING CONFUSING MYSELF.
SO AT THE INFORMAL REVIEW, UM, I HAD PROPOSED THE SHAKE AND, UM, IT WAS EXPRESSED BY BOTH STAFF AND BOARD THAT THEY WERE WORRIED THAT THE HOUSE WOULD GET TOO BUSY.
I THINK WHEN YOU PUT THE DRAWINGS ON, UM, A COMPUTER SCREEN, IT REALLY EMPHASIZES THE, THE HATCH LAYER MORE THAN NECESSARY AND IT MAKES IT LOOK BUSIER.
UM, BUT TAKING THAT INTO CONSIDERATION, I THOUGHT THAT THE, UM, STRAIGHT EDGE VERSUS THE STAGGERED EDGE WOULD SIMPLIFY IT.
UM, I DID PUT IN A POWERPOINT PRESENTATION SHOWING EXAMPLES.
I MEAN, I'M SURE YOU'VE ALL SEEN STAGGERED EDGE AND, AND STRAIGHT EDGE, BUT, UM, JUST BASED ON SEEING THOSE PHOTOS NEXT TO EACH OTHER, I HIGHLY BELIEVE THAT THE STRAIGHT EDGE, ALMOST FROM FAR AWAY CAN, CAN LOOK LIKE LAP SIDING.
UM, SO I, I THOUGHT THAT THAT WOULD BE THE MORE APPROPRIATE CHOICE BASED ON THE INFORMAL PRESENTATION.
I JUST WANTED TO HEAR A LITTLE MORE DETAIL ON THAT.
YEAH, NO, THE ONLY THING I'LL SAY IS I LOVE THE COLOR YOU'RE PICKING FOR THE HOUSE.
THAT'S A COLOR I WANTED AND MY HUSBAND WENT WITH WHITE, SO
I'LL WALK DOWN AND LOOK AT YOUR HOUSE.
SO GET PICTURES TAKEN IN FRONT OF THEIR HOUSE.
RIGHT? I DON'T HAVE ANY, I'M THINK THAT YOU MADE THE CHANGES AND I THINK MM-HMM
WHAT YOU'VE SAID ABOUT HOW YOU KEPT SOME THINGS THE SAME FOR ME ARE OKAY.
I DON'T THINK WE HAD MAJOR ISSUES BEFORE, SO I THINK FOR ME IT'S OKAY.
AND I WASN'T HERE FOR THAT JANUARY PRESENT, BUT YEAH, IT LOOKS GOOD TO ME.
IS THERE ANY PUBLIC COMMENT ON THIS ONE? WE HAD ONE, UH, NOTE THAT WAS INCLUDED IN YOUR PACKET.
UM, ANY OTHER COMMENTS? ANY, ANYBODY HAVE ANY QUESTION? ANY ISSUES WITH THE THREE WAIVERS? NO.
I THINK WE'LL CALL FOR, UH, SEE WE'VE GOT, UH, WE'VE GOT TO APPROVE 'EM.
WE'VE GOT TO APPROVE THE THREE WAIVERS HERE.
SO IF WE HAVE A MOTION FOR THE, UH, WHICH ONE? SARAH WOULD BE BETTER IF WE DO THREE SEPARATE WA THREE SEPARATE MOTIONS ON THE WAIVERS OR ONE, WE'VE DONE IT BOTH WAYS, SO YEAH, I KNOW.
WITH ONE MOTION THAT JUST LISTS WHAT THE THREE WAIVERS ARE, JUST KNOWING THAT IF ANYBODY WANT DOESN'T WANNA APPROVE A SINGLE ONE.
YEAH, I MEAN, WE SHOULD, JAMIE, AND IT'S PROBABLY CLEANER TO SPLIT.
IT'S PROBABLY EASIER TO SPLIT UP AND THEN THAT WAY IF THERE'S AN ISSUE, IT'S EASIER.
IN WHICH CASE I WILL MOVE TO APPROVE THE REAR HEIGHT WAIVER.
AND I WILL MOVE TO APPROVE THE THREE 12 ROOF PITCHES.
AND FINALLY, I WILL MOVE TO APPROVE THE TREX DECKING MATERIALS FOR THE, FOR THE DECK
[00:30:02]
GOOD.NOW IF WE'LL MOVE, IF WE'LL MAKE A MOTION FOR THE, UH, MINOR PROJECT REVIEW.
YOU'RE, YOU'RE ON THE ROLL YEAH.
WITH THE CONDITION AND, AND FOR ME, YOU AGREE, YOU'RE, YOU'RE OKAY WITH, YOU AGREE WITH THE CONDITION THAT'S UP THERE.
SO I MOVE TO APPROVE THE ME PROJECT REVIEW WITH THE CONDITIONS STATED BY STAFF.
[Case #24-142MPR]
CASE NUMBER THREE, UH, CASE 24 DASH 1 42 MINOR PROJECT REVIEW, 40 EAST BRIDGE STREET.REQUEST FOR RE RE REQUEST FOR REVIEW AND APPROVAL OF MINOR PROJECT REVIEW TO ALLOW THE REMODEL AND CONSTRUCTION OF AN ADDITION.
THE 0.0 0.32 ACRE SITE IS ZONED HDHR, HISTORIC RESIDE HISTORIC RESIDENTIAL DISTRICT, AND IS LOCATED NORTHEAST OF THE INTERSECTION OF NORTH BLACK BLACKSMITH LANE AND EAST BRIDGE STREET.
SARAH, ADAM, UP AGAIN AND THANK YOU AGAIN.
THIS LOCATION IS SURROUNDED BY NORTH RIVERVIEW EAST BRIDGE AND NORTH BLACKSMITH.
AS SHOWN IN YELLOW ON THE SCREEN.
IT IS ZONED, UH, HISTORIC RESIDENTIAL AND IT'S ONE OF THREE AUCTION HOUSES SOLD IN OCTOBER OF 23.
THESE PHOTOS PROVIDE THE CONTEXT AND, UM, WE'VE SEEN THESE A NUMBER OF TIMES, SO I'M GONNA ZIP THROUGH THEM A LITTLE BIT.
THIS IS THE NEW FRONT FACADE OF THE HOUSE BASED ON BOARD DETERMINATION AND THE SOUTH FACADE AND THE REAR VIEWS ON BLACKSMITH LANE.
THIS HISTORIC PRIVY IS NOT A PART OF THIS REQUEST TONIGHT IN JANUARY OF 25, UM, WE HAD A BIT OF A DISCUSSION ABOUT WHETHER OR NOT THE PROPOSED EDITION IS SUBORDINATE, AND AT THAT TIME, STAFF MAINTAINED THAT IT WASN'T, BUT IT COULD BE OKAY IF ALL OTHER DETAILS AND, UM, MATERIALS WERE ALL RIGHT.
SO WE ARE NOW COMFORTABLE WITH THE DESIGN, THE MATERIALS, THE INTEGRATION OF THE ADDITION WITH THE HISTORIC HOUSE.
SO WE FEEL LIKE A GOOD BALANCE HAS BEEN ACHIEVED FOR THIS PROJECT.
THE APPLICANT HAS WORKED REALLY HARD TO ADDRESS ALL OF THE CONCERNS, AND, UH, NOW WE'RE RECOMMENDING APPROVAL OF FOUR WAIVERS AND NO CONDITIONS, BUT I GET A LITTLE BIT AHEAD.
IT SHOWS THE REAR YARD SETBACK, UH, RELATIVE TO THE REQUESTED WAIVER.
SO THE REQUIRED SETBACK IS IN BLUE, THE REQUESTED IS AN ORANGE.
THE PREVIOUS REQUEST FOR A LOT COVERAGE WAIVER IS NO LONGER NEEDED.
SO JUST HIGHLIGHTING TONIGHT'S REQUESTS, UH, STICKING WITH THE WAIVERS.
WE HAVE THE SQUARE WINDOWS HERE USED IN TWO INSTANCES ON THE HISTORIC FACADE, ON THE NEW FRONT FACADE.
UM, AND ON THE ADDITION, AND BOTH HAVE THE APPROPRIATE TRIM SILLS, LENTILS AS REQUIRED BY CODE.
AND THEN WE HAVE SOME LOW ROOFS THAT MATCH THE EXISTING LOW ROOFS ON THE BUILDING.
THE NORTH FACADE SHOWS THE HISTORIC HOUSE ON THE LEFT, THE HYPHEN IN THE MIDDLE, THE ADDITION ON THE RIGHT.
THE NEW ENTRY PORCH IS ON THE FAR LEFT, AND IT IS APPROPRIATELY DETAILED.
THE UPPER LEVEL DECKS ARE ON THE RIGHT WITH WOOD RAILINGS.
NOW TO MATCH THE RAILINGS FOR THE ENTRY PORCH, THE GARAGE DOORS ARE BROKEN UP APPROPRIATELY WITH DETAILS AND WINDOWS.
THE SOUTH FACADE IS THE SAME IN REVERSE.
UH, THE HISTORIC PORTION IS NOW ON THE RIGHT, AND HERE THE ORIGINAL WINDOWS, THE FRONT DOOR AND THE TRIM ARE BEING PRESERVED.
AGAIN, THE DECK ON THE ADDITION, ALL OF THOSE RAILINGS MATCH THE HISTORICALLY CORRECT RAILINGS AND DETAILS ON THE FRONT PORCH.
THE AREA FACING BLACKSMITH LANE WAS PROBABLY THE BIGGEST CHANGE SINCE JANUARY.
THIS GABLE FORM HERE HAS BEEN ADDED TO MITIGATE THE FACADE, ESPECIALLY THE
[00:35:01]
SHED ROOF THAT WAS SPANNING THAT ENTIRE, UM, FACADE.IT IS BROUGHT FORWARD THAT GABLE IS BROUGHT FORWARD ABOUT 12 INCHES TO FURTHER BREAK UP THAT FACADE.
AND IT'S PAINTED A LIGHTER SHED, OR I'M SORRY, PAINTED A LIGHTER COLOR TO FURTHER EMPHASIZE THAT BREAKING UP.
SO WE'RE SATISFIED WITH THIS REAR FACADE GOING INTO MATERIALS.
THE HISTORIC HOUSE, THE SIDING IS NOTED TO BE, TO BE PRESERVED WHENEVER POSSIBLE.
UH, STAFF HAS CONFIRMATION ON THAT.
WE WILL BE INVOLVED IN THOSE DECISIONS AND WE WILL BE LOOKING AT THE CONDITION OF THE SIDING.
UH, THE TRIM WILL BE THE SMART SIDE.
THIS WAS APPROVED AT BOTH 17 AND 27 NORTH RIVERVIEW.
THE STANDING SEAM ROOF WILL BE IN BRONZE AND ON THE HISTORIC PART OF THE HOUSE, IT WILL HAVE A WIDER DISTANCE BETWEEN THE SEAMS. THE NEW FRONT DOOR IS MARVIN TRUE STYLE, WHICH IS A WOOD PRODUCT, SO THAT WORKS WELL.
AND THE PORCH DECKING IS THERMALLY MODIFIED WOOD TONGUE AND GROOVE.
SO THAT'S GONNA BE VERY APPROPRIATE TO THE ORIGINAL PORCHES ON THE ADDITION.
AND THESE MATERIALS ARE UP FRONT THERE.
THE FOUNDATION IS GONNA BE THE GREEN TEA ORCHARD LIMESTONE VENEER.
THE SAME STANDING SEAM ROOF WILL BE USED, BUT WITH A NARROWER SPACING.
THE PORCH ROOFS NEED A MEMBRANE ON THEM JUST BECAUSE OF THE VERY FLAT SLOPES.
AND THAT MEMBRANE'S GONNA BE BRONZE.
UM, THE SIDING WILL BE THE THERMALLY MODIFIED WOOD IN A DROP CONFIGURATION.
SO THAT'S THAT LITTLE SCALLOP AT THE TOP.
AND THEN IT COMES DOWN THE NEW DOORS AND NEW WINDOWS ARE MARVIN ULTIMATE ALUMINUM CLAD WOOD WITH BRONZE, BRONZE, UH, FACTORY FINISH.
AND THE GARAGE DOORS ARE CLOPAY RESERVE WOOD.
THE LIGHTING FOR THE FRONT DOOR IS THE ALLENTOWN IN COPPER.
THERE ARE, UM, RESTORATION HARDWARE SCONCES IN BRONZE, AND THE GARAGE GOOSENECKS ARE AS SHOWN HERE FROM MILLENNIUM, ALSO IN BRONZE.
THE HALF ROUND GUTTERS AND DOWNSPOUTS ARE IN BRONZE AND ALSO THE CHIMNEY CAP.
THE COLOR SCHEME IS BASED ON THE PRE-APPROVED COLOR LIST.
AND THE HISTORIC AND ADDITION BODY IS THAT MIDTONE GRAY.
THE FINNEY GRAY, ALSO THE HYPHEN.
AND THIS RESPONDS TO BOARD DIRECTION TO KIND OF, UM, HOMOGENIZE MAYBE, OR USE MORE OF A SINGLE COLOR FOR THE BULK OF THE BUILDING.
THE SECOND FLOOR ON THE HISTORIC PORTION IS THE LIGHTER YORK GRAY.
THAT'S GONNA EMPHASIZE THE SHINGLES, THE SCALLOP SHINGLES, THE REAR ELEVATION, THAT GABLE PORTION THAT'S COMING FORWARD A LITTLE BIT IS THAT LIGHTER YORK GRAY.
ALL TRIM DECKING AND RAILINGS AND COLUMNS ARE GOING TO BE THE GUNSMITH GRAY.
SO, UM, WE ARE HAPPY WITH THIS COMBINATION WITH THE BRONZE ACCENTS AND WINDOWS AND DOORS.
THESE ARE THE COLOR RENDERINGS THAT THE APPLICANT PROVIDED THAT GIVE A LITTLE BIT MORE SENSE OF HOW THAT COLOR IS GOING TO LOOK.
AND THEN FOR THE SIDE ELEVATIONS AS WELL, FOUR WAIVERS ARE REQUESTED.
ONE IS THE REAR SETBACK, ONE IS FOR THE QUARTER TO 12 INCH ROOF PITCH, UH, THE SQUARE WINDOWS, AND THEN THE SMART SIDE TRIM.
SO STAFF SUPPORTS ALL OF THESE AS OUTLINED IN THE REPORT.
FINALLY, ALL OF THE MINOR PROJECT REVIEW CRITERIA HAVE BEEN MET, MET WITH THE WAIVERS, OR ARE NOT APPLICABLE.
SO AGAIN, WE'RE RECOMMENDING APPROVAL OF ALL FOUR WAIVERS AND APPROVAL OF THE MINOR PROJECT WITH NO CONDITIONS.
[00:40:01]
QUESTIONS.ANY CLARIFYING? JUST MAYBE ONE SARAH.
AND JUST ON ONE SETBACK, PART OF THAT SETBACK IS THE DRIVEWAY, RIGHT? I, I DIDN'T REALIZE IT BEFORE, BUT IF YOU GO TO THIS IN THE BEGINNING, IT'S ACTUALLY NOT THE, IS THAT THE SETBACK OF THE, THE PUSHED OUT PART, OR IS IT THE DRIVEWAY THAT EXTENDS INTO THE AMANDA JUST DIDN'T SEE IT VERY CLEARLY ON THE DRAWING WHEN I WAS LOOKING HERE, SO THAT'S, SO, OKAY.
SO IT'S REALLY, IT'S THE PAVED PART THAT ACTUALLY EXTENDS MORE, IT'S THE ADDITION THAT REALLY EXTENDS.
SO THE YELLOW, DOES THAT MAKE SENSE? YEAH, JUST THE YELLOW IS, IT'S DELINEATING WHAT? OH, MY APOLOGIES.
THAT LINE IS IN THE WRONG SPOT.
IS THAT THE RIGHT OF WAY,
IT SHOULD BE AT THE VERY BACK OF THE HOUSE.
I JUST, YES, IT'S BACK, THE BACK OF THE HOUSE FOR CATCHING THAT.
NO, I HAVE THE SAME QUESTION, SO, OKAY.
KELLY BURKE 4, 3, 8, 9 HUNTERS BEND IN POWELL, OHIO.
ANY, ANYTHING TO ADD OR FOLLOW UP FROM, FROM SARAH'S PRESENTATION? NO, I MEAN, IT'S BEEN A LONG ROAD, BUT I'M GLAD WE GOT HERE.
UM, YOU KNOW, IT GETS FRUSTRATING WHEN YOU'RE IN THE MIDST OF IT, BUT I UNDERSTAND WHY AND KIND OF SEE THE LIGHT AT THIS POINT.
I, I HAVE TO ADMIT, I, I MEAN, I, I HAVE TO SAY I'M FROM, FROM MY SIDE, I APPRECIATE TRYING TO WORK AROUND, UH, WHERE, WHERE WE WANNA MAKE SURE THAT THE CODE AND THE GUIDELINES ALL FIT INTO, INTO WHERE WE'RE, WHERE WE'RE TRYING TO GET TO WITH, UH, WITH THE, WITH THE, WITH THE NEW BUILD.
AND, AND IT'S CERTAINLY AN IMPORTANT SPOT IN THE CITY.
I MEAN, IT'S A DIFFICULT LOT AND HOUSE AND ALL THAT, SO.
IT'S GONNA TURN OUT BEAUTIFUL.
I, I THINK THANK YOU FOR WORKING WITH US.
AND I KNOW IT WAS FRUSTRATING, BUT I THINK YOU'VE GOT A REALLY GOOD OUTCOME.
THE PRODUCT'S BETTER THIS WAY, AND I, PATIENCE IS NOT MY BEST VERSION.
IT WAS DIFFICULT, SO YEAH, ABSOLUTELY.
WE'RE VERY APPRECIATIVE THAT YOU STUCK WITH IT AND YEAH.
I DON'T, I DON'T HAVE ANY COMMENT.
I THINK YOU DID, YOU DID A NICE JOB.
I THINK IT, IT, IT SOFTENS ALL THINGS AS YOU SAY IT.
WELL, YOU KNOW, IT'S NOT WHAT TRADITIONALLY SUBORDINATE, BUT WHAT YOU'VE DONE IS MADE IT SOFTEN AND INTO THE, INTO WHERE, WHERE IT'S GONNA SIT.
SO I SAY ON OUR SIDE, I THINK WE APPRECIATE YOU WORKING WITH THE CITY.
FRUSTRATING AS IT AS IT CAN BE ON SOMETIMES, BUT IS THERE ANY PUBLIC COMMENT THAT WE NO PUBLIC COMMENT.
SO IF WE DON'T HAVE ANY OTHER ONES, THEN MAYBE WE DO.
SAME KYLE, WE DID IF WE GO THROUGH THE, GO THROUGH THE, UM, UH, THROUGH THE WAIVERS.
I VOLUNTEER TO BE THE MOVEMENT.
I MOVE THAT WE APPROVE A WAIVER FOR THE QUARTER TO 12 ROOF PITCHES.
I MOVE TO APPROVE A WAIVER TO PROVIDE OR TO PERMIT SQUARE WINDOWS.
AND FINALLY, I MOVE TO APPROVE A WAIVER FOR SMART SIDE TRIM.
SMOOTH OF THE SMOOTH TYPE, I DUNNO HOW TO PHRASE.
ANY STUDY YOU HAVE ANY COMMENTS ON APPROVAL OF THE MINOR PROJECT? ALL RIGHT.
I MOVE TO APPROVE THE MINOR PROJECT REVIEW WITHOUT CONDITIONS AND I'LL SECOND THAT.
THAT WENT QUICK,
[COMMUNICATIONS]
OR THERE WAS SOME COMMUNICATION? JUST A COUPLE.FIRST OF ALL, STAFF WANTS TO THANK MIKE JEWEL FOR HIS SERVICE OVER THE PAST THREE YEARS NOW, AND FOUR.
[00:45:01]
FOR BEING HERE AND BRINGING THAT UNIQUE PERSPECTIVE FROM THE HISTORICAL SOCIETY AND ALSO YOUR OWN PERSONAL EXPERIENCE.AND I'M SURE I'LL MISS EVERYBODY ELSE.
WELL, SO I'LL BE IN WATCHING FROM AFAR.
AND CERTAINLY I THINK FROM THE BOARD, MIKE, I MEAN, WE APPRECIATE KIND OF YOUR DEMEANOR, EVERYTHING YOU BRING.
I MEAN, CERTAINLY BEING ON THE HISTORIC SOCIETY, YOU WENT TO CONFERENCES, ALL THINGS TO TRY TO HELP MAKE SURE THAT WE, UH, I'LL SAY WE, ME SPECIFICALLY, UH, WE, WE MAINTAIN WHERE, WHERE SOME OF THE ARCH HISTORIC ARCHITECTURE COMES, AS COMES TOGETHER.
'CAUSE UM, CERTAINLY IT'S, IT'S A SPOT THAT'S NOT MY EXPERTISE.
SO I REALLY APPRECIATE YOU GOING TO DO THAT.
AND I THINK FROM THE BOARD'S PERSPECTIVE, WHAT YOU BROUGHT EVERY, EVERY MONTH, UH, WAS GREAT.
AND, AND I'D SAY FOR ME SPECIFICALLY, I APPRECIATE ALL THE, ALL THE TIME YOU PUT IN ALL THE EFFORT, AND NOW YOU CAN, UH, YEAH.
GET YOUR WEDNESDAY NIGHTS FREE.
BUT, UH, BUT YOU KNOW, CERTAINLY IF YOU WANNA COME AND YEAH.
IF YOU NEED TO COME AND HECKLE OR SOMETHING, YOU CAN ALSO WELCOME.
NO, I THINK YOUR COMMENTS, AND WE REMEMBER SOME OF THOSE DAYS TALKING ABOUT WINDOWS
SO I HAVE A TOTAL BETTER RESPECT OF WINDOWS NOW OF ALL THE CONFERENCES I WENT TALKING ABOUT WINDOWS.
BUT NO, IT, IT'S A GREAT BOARD AND GET, UM, UH, CONTINUE WITH A GREAT BOARD AND, UM, IT'S GREAT FOR THE COMMUNITY.
ALSO, ON THAT NOTE, ON THE 2ND OF JUNE, THERE'S GONNA BE THE SWEARING IN OF OUR NEW MEMBER AND A CELEBRATION FOR NEW MEMBERS AND OLD MEMBERS AND APPRECIATION.
AND, UM, YOU SHOULD HAVE A INVITATION FOR THAT IN YOUR ONBOARD INFORMATION.
UM, ALSO ADDED TO YOUR ONBOARD INFORMATION.
I'M HAVING SO MUCH FUN WITH THIS, UM, THE HISTORIC DISTRICT CHAPTER, AND IT'S A DRAFT FORM YET, BUT THIS ISN'T, THE INFORMATION'S NOT GOING TO CHANGE.
THIS IS THE PARKING STUDY THAT WAS DONE FOR THE HISTORIC DISTRICT WITH ALL OF THE DATA ABOUT HOW EMPTY OR FULL THE LOTS AND PARKING GARAGES ARE.
SO THIS IS REALLY, REALLY GOOD DATA AS WE GET, UM, PARKING PLAN REQUESTS COMING FORWARD.
WHERE IS THAT IN RESOURCES? IT'S UNDER RESOURCES, RESOURCES, RESOURCES, CODE AND CHARTER.
JUST TRYING TO, IS IT UNDER RE IT RESOURCES, DRAFT HISTORIC DISTRICT OR CURB MANAGEMENT.
WHAT DID WE END UP CALLING THAT? CURBSIDE MANAGEMENT.
SO IF YOU GO TO RESOURCES, ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW, BOARD RESOURCES, AND THEN REFERENCE MATERIALS.
REFERENCE, AND IT IS A DRAFT, SARAH REFERRING TO IT AS LIBRARY, BUT THAT'S PROBABLY, WE SHOULD PROBABLY START CALLING IT RESOURCE MATERIALS JUST SO WE CAN FIND IT BETTER.
I'M NOT CHASTISING YOU
AND THAT, AGAIN, THAT IS A DRAFT DOCUMENT.
NOT FULLY ADOPTED BY CITY COUNCIL YET, BUT THIS EXCERPT IS VERY IMPORTANT FOR THE WORK THAT YOU ALL DO.
UM, AND ON A SIMILAR VEIN, UNDER THE, UH, NATIONAL ALLIANCE OF PRESERVATION COMMISSIONS, YOU HAVE A, UNDER YOUR RESOURCES SECTION, THERE'S AN NAPC.
JUNE'S MAGAZINE IS IN THERE AND IT'S ALL ABOUT, UM, IT'S ALL ABOUT WINDOW REPLACEMENTS,
AND, UM, I'M JUST, IT'S LIKE A 53 PAGE DOCUMENT THAT I'M WORKING MY WAY THROUGH, BUT IT SHOULD BE GOOD.
JUST SOME LIGHT READING, RIGHT? EXACTLY.
BUT THAT'S ALL I, I NEED MU A MU, IT'S A BUTTON.
IT'S UNDER NATIONAL RESOURCE NATIONAL PARK.
NATIONAL ALLIANCE OF PRESERVATION COMMISSIONS.
SO IT, UM, THE MAGAZINE'S UNDER THERE.
BRING, WHY AM I NOT FINDING IT? I'M, YEAH.
I SEE JANUARY 22ND EMERGING IS FOR PRESERVATION.
OH, MAYBE IT'S NOT UPLOADED YET BECAUSE THAT'S ALL.
IT'S THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF PRESERVATION COMMISSIONS RESOURCES FOLDER.
[00:50:01]
FINE.BUT IT'LL BE GOOD READING WHEN YOU GET IT.
WELL, I CAN READ THE PREVIOUS ONE.
WE GET THOSE ELECTRONICALLY EVERY QUARTER.
SO I WILL SEND THEM ALONG TO YOU ALL.
ANYTHING FROM ANYBODY ELSE? STAFF? NO.
THEN I'LL CALL THE MEETING ADJOURNED.
IS THAT A RECORD? THAT MIGHT, THAT MIGHT BE A RECORD.